Theme Buffets

The Fantasticks Theme Buffet
April 25, May 2, 23
Soon It's Gonna Rain

Soup

  • Watered Down Tomato Bisque

Appetizers

  • Fantastickers Sweet and Sour Wings
  • Salad Mixed Up Greens with the Blues Cheese
  • Breads Neighborly Loaves of Multi-Grain

Entrees

  • Steaks on the Grill
  • Poached King Salmon

Pasta

  • Picnic Whole Wheat Pasta and Shrimp

Vegetables

  • Try to Remember You Like Spinach
  • Tom Jones Jullian Vegetables

Desserts

  • Stick Together Caramel Tarts
  • Harvey Schmidt Chocolate Pie
  • Brenda's Famous Crème Brule'

Beverages

  • Rain
  • Alcohol Free Wines
  • Sparkling Juices
  • Iced Tea
  • Lemonade
  • Coffees


Plain and Fancy Theme Buffet
June 6
Plenty of Pennsylvania

Soup

  • Broccoli Soup

Appetizers

  • Glazed Grapes
  • Watermelon Pickles

Salad

  • Dandelion Greens and Escarole with Tomatoes, Unions
  • Iceberg Lettuce Quarters

Bread

  • Zucchini Bread
  • Quince Jam

Entrees

  • Swiss Steak with Mushrooms
  • Pan Fried Chicken
  • Stuffed Squash with Ground Beef

Vegetables

  • Asparagus
  • Cauliflower and Peas
  • Candied Yams
  • Cooked Dried Corn

Desserts

  • Honeydew Melon with Honey
  • Oatmeal Whoopie Pie
  • Lemon Meringue Pie
  • Shoofly Pie
  • Brenda's Famous Crème Brule'

Beverages

  • Raspberry Vinegar
  • Alcohol Free Wines
  • Sparkling Juices
  • Iced Tea
  • Lemonade
  • CoffeesAmish Acres

The Music Man Theme Buffet
June 20, 27, July 11
Big Band Buffet

Soup

  • Mayor Shinn's Chicken Noodle Soup

Appetizers

  • Winthrop's Devilish Eggs
  • Lay an Eggplant Antipasto

Salad

  • Fresh Greens from Gary Indiana
  • Marian Librarian Crab Delights

Bread

  • Bruschetta with Shipoppy Shallots

Entrees

  • Wells Fargo Wagon Chuck
  • Harold Hill Ham, Glazed Over

Pasta

  • Zaneeta Shinn Baked Ziti

Vegetables

  • Amaryllis Sweetest Potatoes
  • Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn 's Succotash

Desserts

  • Ethel Toffelmier Toffee Pie
  • Meredith Willson Peaches with Raspberry Puree
  • Brenda's Famous Crème Brule'

Beverages

  • Lida Rose Water
  • Alcohol Free Wines
  • Sparkling Juices
  • Iced Tea
  • Lemonade
  • Coffees

Amish Acres

Carousel Theme Buffet
August 8, 15, 22
It's a Clam Bake

Soup

  • New England Style Clam Chowder

Appetizers

  • Corn Dogs Fritters

Salad

  • June is Bustin' Broccoli Salad

Breads

  • Richard Rodgers Hot Rolls

Entrees

  • Baked Clams with Sun Dried Tomatos
  • Veal Oscar Hammerstein

Pasta

  • Agnes de Mille Twisted Pasta

Vegetables

  • Julie Jordan Red Bliss Potatoes
  • If I Loved You Mixed Up Vegetables

Desserts

  • Billy Bigelow's Sweet Nothings
  • Bluesberry Pie
  • Brenda's Famous Crème Brule'

Beverages

  • Summer Cider
  • Alcohol Free Wines
  • Sparkling Juices
  • Iced Tea
  • Lemonade
  • Coffees

Amish Acres

Kiss Me, Kate Theme Buffet
September 26, October 3, 17, 24
Arguably the Best Buffet

Soup

  • Chilled Cucumber Soup

Appetizers

  • Lost My Appetizers

Salad

  • Tony Award Winning Waldorf Salad

Bread

  • Wry Breads

Entrees

  • Taming of the Stew Cole Porterhouse Steak

Pasta

  • Petruccio's Penne Pasta

Vegetables

  • Too Darn Hot Potatoes
  • Shakespeares of Asparagus

Desserts

  • Wunderbars Kate's Chocolate Kisses
  • Brenda's Famous Crème Brule'

Beverages

  • Raspberry Bitters
  • Alcohol Free Wines
  • Sparkling Juices
  • Iced Tea
  • Lemonade
  • Coffees

Amish Acres

A Wonderful Life Theme Buffet
November 14, December 5, 12, 19
A Wonderful Holiday Feast

Soup

  • Yuletide Oyster Soup

Appetizers

  • Clarence's Wings

Salad

  • Mixed Up Garden Greens/Bittersweet Dressing

Breads

  • George Bailey's Wonderful Biscuits with Whipped Honey

Entrees

  • Jimmy Stewart Sirloin Christmas Goose with Chestnut Stuffing

Pasta

  • Red and Green Pasta with Scallops

Vegetables

  • Bedford Falls Baked Corn
  • Mr. Potter's Stingy Spinich and Bacon

Desserts

  • Frank Capra Capers
  • Egg Nog Pound Cake with Rum Sauce
  • Brenda's Famous Crème Brule'

Beverages

  • Holiday Egg Nog and Grog
  • Alcohol Free Wines
  • Sparkling Juices
  • Iced Tea
  • Lemonade
  • Coffees

Shop Online

Amish Acres Shopping

 

Menu
The Threshers Menu that has been served for over three decades.

Recipes
A sampling of the recipes carefully prepared in Amish Acres kitchen.

The Barn Loft Grill
Serves light lunches during the summer months.

Theme Buffets
Artistically designed to complement each repertory musical in the Round Barn Theatre.

Our Recipe Cookbook
Our most popular cookbook with recipes from Amish Acres Threshers Dinner, Theme Buffets, and area favorites.

A Diner's Online Review
"Thank you for providing my husband and I with such a great weekend!"